Episode 60: Why Americans Talk to Strangers

[00:00:00] Welcome to English, please, the podcast where we explore interesting topics in under 10 minutes in clear, intermediate English. I’m your host, Christopher. I live in New York City, and I’ve always been passionate about languages and how we learn them. Whether you’re listening on your way to work or while cooking dinner at home, this show is designed to help you with your English listening and comprehension skills.

Thanks so much for being here. By the way, this is Episode 60 of English, please. If you’re new to the show, welcome! There are 59 more episodes waiting for you wherever you listen. And if you’re enjoying the show, the best thing you can do is follow it. [00:01:00] That helps more people find us!

Before we get started, a quick note if you would like some extra practice. After you listen, you can subscribe to the free newsletter at comullen.com/newsletter. Sign up and you’ll receive a free sample lesson by email, plus English practice tips and activities with each new episode.

Okay, let’s go!

Have you ever experienced something like this? You are waiting in line at a coffee shop and you don’t know anyone around you. The person next to you says, “Can you believe how long this line is?” and smiles. They’re not angry, and they’re not looking for a real answer. They’re just talking to you.

If this has ever felt strange or confusing, you are not alone. And once you understand why Americans do [00:02:00] this, it will never feel strange again.

In many countries, talking to a stranger without a clear reason feels unusual, or even a little suspicious. But in the United States, it’s completely normal. Americans talk to strangers all the time—in elevators, in waiting rooms, at the gym, and in line at the grocery store. If you don’t understand why, it can feel confusing or even fake.

So let’s talk about why it happens, and then I’ll give you some real phrases so you can understand it, and even participate.

The first thing to understand is that small talk with strangers is not about getting information, and it is not about starting a friendship. It’s kind of a social glue, a way of saying, “I see you. I am [00:03:00] friendly. This moment is pleasant.” Think of it like a small gift. The other person is not asking for anything back. They’re just making the space feel a little bit warmer.

The second thing to understand is that Americans are often uncomfortable with silence in shared social situations—waiting in line, riding an elevator, sitting in a waiting room. These moments can feel awkward if no one says anything, and a small comment breaks that tension and makes everyone feel more at ease. This is especially common in smaller cities and towns, but even in a busy place like New York City, you’ll hear it every single day.

Now if you want to get better at hearing and understanding exactly this kind of natural, everyday English, the kind that happens in real [00:04:00] life and not in textbooks, I made something for you. It’s called the English Listening Accelerator, and it’s a workbook with audio and 10 lessons, and each one focuses on a different part of natural spoken English. You can try a free sample lesson at comullen.com/listen. That’s C-O-M-U-L-L-E-N dot com slash listen. And the full workbook is just $7.

So what does this small talk actually sound like? Here are some phrases you will hear Americans say to strangers.

“Can you believe this weather?” This is one of the most classic small talk openers. The weather is a safe topic because everyone experiences it, and it doesn’t require a personal answer. A simple “I know, right?” [00:05:00] or even just a smile and a nod is all you need.

“That’s a great bag. Where did you get it?” A small friendly compliment to a stranger is very common in the U.S., among both men and women. It’s not flirting and it’s not strange. It’s really just a friendly gesture. A good response is something like, “Oh, thank you. I got it online.” Simple and warm, and you don’t need to say anything more than that

“Have a good one.” You’ll hear this constantly from cashiers, doormen, people passing you on the street, taxi drivers. It means “Have a good day,” “Have a good night,” or “Have a good weekend,” and the right response is just “You too,” or “Thanks, you as well.”

“Staying warm out there?” or “Can you believe how hot it is?” These are [00:06:00] seasonal variations of the weather opener, and they work in the same way. The person is not really asking about your temperature, they are just making a small human connection.

And one more situation. If someone holds an elevator door for you, a simple “Thank you” with a smile is enough. You might also hear “Which floor? which is practical, but always said warmly.

Now, one thing worth knowing is that in many other cultures, not responding to a stranger is perfectly normal. It does not mean you are rude. It just means you are minding your own business, which is completely acceptable.

In the U.S. though, not responding at all with no eye contact, no smile, nothing, can feel quite cold to the person who spoke. You don’t need to have a conversation, but a small smile, a nod, or a brief [00:07:00] word, goes a long way.

A short, warm response is all that’s expected.

So the next time a stranger says something to you out of nowhere, you don’t need to feel suspicious or confused. They’re not trying to sell you something, and they’re not being fake. They’re just doing what Americans do, which is filling the space with a little warmth. And now you have the language to understand and to respond.

If you want help hearing more of that natural everyday English, the English Listening Accelerator is waiting for you at comullen.com/listen.

Again, I’m Christopher, and I want to invite you to join me in future episodes of English, please to hear about a variety of topics, all focused on helping you with your English. Subscribe now wherever you listen to podcasts, and let’s continue this adventure together in clear, understandable English.

Sincere thanks as always for your support.

See you soon!